Public Media for Central Pennsylvania
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Plant-based restaurants are adding beef. Does the climate math add up?


The salad chain restaurant Sweetgreen surprised a lot of people when they recently said they would begin serving beef. And Los Angeles area vegans got an even bigger shock. The restaurant chain formerly known as Sage Vegan says they will soon offer meat and dairy. These restaurants highlight their sustainable goals, but beef and dairy are huge sources of planet-warming pollution. Both restaurants say the beef would come from farms that practice what's known as regenerative farming. But what does this actually mean for the climate? To learn more, we are joined by Julia Simon from NPR's Climate Desk. Hey.

JULIA SIMON, BYLINE: Thanks for having me.

KEITH: Start at the beginning. What is regenerative farming? What - how does it work?

SIMON: So a step back - soil has the potential to draw down carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it, but many conventional farming practices end up releasing carbon. Regenerative agriculture is this umbrella term for a bunch of farming practices different from conventional farming that can, in theory, be better for the soil and the environment.

KEITH: So, give us an example of how regenerative farming is different from conventional farming.

SIMON: Yeah, so one example is cover crops, which basically means that there's always some kind of plant like grasses or legumes on your fields, versus conventional farming, letting fields lie fallow. Emily Oldfield, a soil scientist at the Environmental Defense Fund, says that can help lead to more healthy soil.

EMILY OLDFIELD: You're preventing against soil loss and erosion. You're maximizing the presence of living roots, so you're sort of feeding all those microbes that are down in there.

KEITH: OK, I get it for plants, but explain - these restaurants say that their beef is coming from regenerative farms. How does it work with livestock?

SIMON: There's something called regenerative grazing where you're managing the way livestock like cattle graze on grasses to improve soil health among other things.

KEITH: Regenerative agriculture often gets discussed in the context of climate solutions. Does it reduce emissions?

SIMON: Yeah. There are ways it could, but some scientists worry about some climate benefits getting overstated.

KEITH: Give us an example there.

SIMON: Scientists say that keeping soils more intact can increase the amount of carbon stored in them, which is good, right? Carbon dioxide - it's a planet-heating gas. Great to have carbon in the soil versus the atmosphere - but there are lots of questions about how much carbon gets stored in the soil by changing these practices and, critically, how long the carbon stays in the soil. Here's Eric Slessarev, professor at Yale University.

ERIC SLESSAREV: Organic matter in soil is live material. There are microorganisms living on it, and they're constantly breaking it down and releasing it as CO2. It goes back to the atmosphere. And so soil is not a sealed-off compartment. It's dynamic.

SIMON: Also things like drought, heat, can affect the amount of carbon that soil stores. And while a farmer might be doing regenerative farming now, there's no guarantee that they'll be doing these practices into the future. Slessarev says, this is a big question mark over climate claims around regenerative agriculture.

SLESSAREV: In my mind, that is the biggest uncertainty - is how long is that carbon going to stay out of the atmosphere if it ends up in the soil in the form of organic matter?

KEITH: So regenerative farming does not sound like an exact science at this point, and the long-term climate benefits may be in question. But in terms of beef, the climate impacts are pretty clear, right?

SIMON: Right. The main reason cattle heat the planet so much is that cattle burp, and those burps have a lot of methane, this very potent greenhouse gas. Also in much of the world, making room for cattle and food for cattle drives deforestation, which also heats the planet.

KEITH: I want to ask about these companies, Sweetgreen and Sage Vegan, which on its website now says it is rebranding as Sage Regenerative. What do they have to say about all of this?

SIMON: Both Sweetgreen and Sage Regenerative did not respond to NPR's requests for comments. But again, we should say regenerative agriculture does have lots of environmental benefits. These practices are really good for soils. They can reduce erosion, water runoff.

The questions come with the claimed climate benefits. Ultimately, experts I spoke to say when it comes to climate emissions from food, there might be an impulse to tweak around the edges, but meaningful emissions reductions will have to focus on the big sources of emissions, like cattle. Research shows just swapping out beef in a meal can have a big impact on a person's daily climate emissions.

KEITH: And our doctors might suggest the same. That's NPR's Julia Simon. Thanks, Julia.

SIMON: Thank you, Tamara.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Tamara Keith has been a White House correspondent for NPR since 2014 and co-hosts the NPR Politics Podcast, the top political news podcast in America. Keith has chronicled the Trump administration from day one, putting this unorthodox presidency in context for NPR listeners, from early morning tweets to executive orders and investigations. She covered the final two years of the Obama presidency, and during the 2016 presidential campaign she was assigned to cover Hillary Clinton. In 2018, Keith was elected to serve on the board of the White House Correspondents' Association.
Julia Simon
Julia Simon is the Climate Solutions reporter on NPR's Climate Desk. She covers the ways governments, businesses, scientists and everyday people are working to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. She also works to hold corporations, and others, accountable for greenwashing.